This week’s question from our portal “Ask Us Anything” comes from someone who wishes to remain anonymous.

"We closed on buying a company recently and have just found out that they never remitted vacation pay to one of their employees, going back years. Our purchase agreement has a working capital adjustment and it also has an indemnity section. Which one should we be using to recover that money, and is there a deadline I need to worry about?"

Good question — and the fact that you are asking before the adjustment statement is final is the part that will save you.
In most purchase agreements, unremitted vacation pay that accrued before closing is a current liability, which means the working capital adjustment is usually the cleaner route.
That adjustment runs through what your agreement probably calls the true-up. At closing you paid a price that assumed the business would carry an agreed level of working capital. Afterwards, the accountants work out what the working capital actually was on the closing date and compare it to that agreed target, and whichever side comes up short pays the difference. A pre-closing liability nobody knew about pulls the actual figure down, so it flows back to you as money.
It is a calculation rather than a claim. An indemnity claim chases the same money, but it is a contractual procedure with notice requirements and thresholds attached.
Why the true-up is usually simpler comes down to what you have to prove. With the adjustment, you are doing arithmetic against a defined target. You do not have to establish that a representation was breached, you do not have to clear a basket or a deductible, and you do not have to argue about whether the seller’s disclosure was adequate. If the liability existed at closing and your agreement’s definition of working capital captures accrued employee entitlements, it belongs in the true-up.
The indemnity still matters in two situations. If the liability sits outside how your agreement defines working capital, the true-up cannot reach it. And if it is larger than the adjustment can absorb, the indemnity is what gets you the rest — sometimes as a set-off against a vendor take-back note, which is worth real money if you are still paying the seller.
Now the part people miss. Your agreement almost certainly gives the accountants a fixed window to deliver the post-closing adjustment statement, and gives you a shorter window after that to object to it. Those clocks run whether or not you have finished working out what the liability is worth. If your number is not ready, do not wait for it — file a notice of objection inside the window, identify the item, and reserve your position on the amount. Miss that window and the statement can become final and binding, which closes off the cleaner of your two routes.
So, practically: pull the agreement and check three things before you do anything else. How working capital is defined, and whether accrued vacation pay falls inside it. The deadline for the adjustment statement. And the length of your objection period.
One last thing, because it is easy to lose in the middle of a recovery argument. The liability itself does not pause while you sort out who ultimately pays for it. Vacation pay is a statutory entitlement under Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, and having bought the company, you are the employer now. Get the remittance corrected first, then recover it second.
This answer is general legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot account for the facts of your situation. Always speak with a lawyer before you act on it.
P.S. If a question like this one has come up in your own business, schedule a complimentary discovery call with our firm and we will walk through it with you.



